# Riddle #673

Question: A hobo picks up cigarette butts from the ground and can make a cigarette with 4 butts. If he finds 16 cigarette butts, how many cigarettes can he make?

Riddle Discussion

By: Mongreller on 13/7/16

It depends on whether you think that all butts are identical, which is clearly absurd. If you think that all butts are identical, then the answer is 5. If you think that no two butts are identical, then there are C(16,4)C(12,4)C(8,4)(4!)^4 cigarettes the hobo can make. (He can only smoke 5 distinct combinations, though.) If you think that some butts are identical and some distinct then the world is a very complicated place for you.\n\nIncidentally, I have seen a hobo picking up cigarette butts on several occasions, but never a male hobo. I never realized until just now.)

### Similar Riddles

##### ???? (medium)

Question: What can be broken but never forgotten?

##### What am I? (medium)

By Bist

Question: People see through me, but none pass through without killing me. I can be anywhere, and can be seen double or single. What am I?

##### Brain teaser (medium)

Question: Which thing that comes once in a year, twice in a week?

##### The Chicken, Fox, Wheat, and you (medium)

Question: You are trying to get your chicken, fox, and wheat to the barn. However, the barn is on the other side of the river. You are on a boat and can only transport one animal or wheat at a time. You must choose carefully not to leave the wrong two together, though. It's either the fox will eat the chicken or the chicken will eat the wheat. How do you take each thing across safely?

##### Can you ? (medium)

Question: If 4+5=24 7+2=21 9+6=63 6+7=?